Summary
So, I finally got around to reading The Screwtape Letters.
In it, Screwtape, a senior devil, an administrator in the department of temptation writes letters to his nephew, Wormwood, a junior devil, giving advice on how to be a more effective tempter.
What I liked
In his letters, Screwtape explains God's plan for humans and how the devils try to disrupt it through temptation.
What I didn't like
Screwtape seems to think that people are saved by their works. I'm not sure if this reflects C.S. Lewis' thinking or if it's wishful thinking on Screwtape's part.
In the last part of the book, Screwtape makes a long winded speech. It wasn't so interesting.
Summary
A great book. 4.9/5 devils.
Sunday, July 18, 2010
Tuesday, July 13, 2010
The Dragon Reborn by Robert Jordan
Summary
The third book of the Wheel of Time series picks up shortly after the last book left off.
Perrin is camped in the mountains with Loial, Lan, Moirainne, and their small group of Shienaran soldiers. Rand is there too, but he's kind of sullen and seems to be going a little crazy. And then he runs away. Perrin, Loial, Lan, and Moirainne go after him, chasing him back across the continent. They suspect he is going to Tear where the next Dragon prophecy is supposed to be fulfilled. Along the way, a girl named Zarine decides to follow Perrin because he has broad shoulders and a strong back.
Mat wakes up in Tar Valon, ravenously hungry and incredibly lucky. The rulers of Tar Valon take precautions against his escaping but Mat is kind of stubborn. And lucky. So he hatches some kind of hare brained plan and goes off gambling and wins more money than he can carry in his wallet. Then he finds Thom Merrilin, the gleeman from book one, and convinces him to accompany him. Together, and with a letter they sneakily acquired from the Amirlyn Seat, they leave Tar Valon, heading for Caemlyn to deliver a letter from the Daughter-Heir of Andor to her mother, the Queen. In Caemlyn, Mat (by chance) discovers a vile plot and turns south, to Tear, to warn his friends about a terrible trap.
Egwene, Nynaeve, and Elayne are ordered by the Amirlyn Seat to find and bring to justice the members of the Black Ajah that kidnapped them in book two. The trail leads them south towards Tear.
This book has considerably less action than the previous two. Instead it is filled with intrigue, a little politics, and plenty of drama. The pace is much slower than the previous, there is more thinking and planning and unfolding than there is action.
What I liked
It was interesting and kept me reading. And a little suspenseful, though less so than the previous two.
It was funny, in many places. For example, Rand passes through a village on his way to Tear and as he goes by everyone in the village decides to get married. Rand ends up playing the pipes at the wedding celebrations that last all day long and leave the poor villagers all exhausted. When Moirraine, Perrin, Lan, and Loial come through the village on Rand's trail, Moirraine's explanation is: the pattern of the ages shifts around Rand.
Another example: The bunch following Rand stop in an inn in Illian where a girl is dancing and singing and playing the harp. All her songs involve either a man who makes a complete idiot of himself by the end or a woman who ends up completely naked. Sometimes both. And in improbable and hilarious circumstances. Very clever.
I also liked the character development in this book.
It's also a little scary, what with all the creepy gray men skulking in shadows and trying to stick knives in peoples backs or shoot them with crossbows.
And the dream world is a pretty imaginative and cool idea.
What I didn't like
Oh the drama. Same as the last two in that respect. The series is kind of frustrating with all its drama. Part of me wants to give it up altogether but I'm just curious enough to crack open the next book... And once I have, the suspense in that one keeps me reading.
Conclusion
I guess I have to rate it the same as the previous one. 4/5 shadowy assassins.
The third book of the Wheel of Time series picks up shortly after the last book left off.
Perrin is camped in the mountains with Loial, Lan, Moirainne, and their small group of Shienaran soldiers. Rand is there too, but he's kind of sullen and seems to be going a little crazy. And then he runs away. Perrin, Loial, Lan, and Moirainne go after him, chasing him back across the continent. They suspect he is going to Tear where the next Dragon prophecy is supposed to be fulfilled. Along the way, a girl named Zarine decides to follow Perrin because he has broad shoulders and a strong back.
Mat wakes up in Tar Valon, ravenously hungry and incredibly lucky. The rulers of Tar Valon take precautions against his escaping but Mat is kind of stubborn. And lucky. So he hatches some kind of hare brained plan and goes off gambling and wins more money than he can carry in his wallet. Then he finds Thom Merrilin, the gleeman from book one, and convinces him to accompany him. Together, and with a letter they sneakily acquired from the Amirlyn Seat, they leave Tar Valon, heading for Caemlyn to deliver a letter from the Daughter-Heir of Andor to her mother, the Queen. In Caemlyn, Mat (by chance) discovers a vile plot and turns south, to Tear, to warn his friends about a terrible trap.
Egwene, Nynaeve, and Elayne are ordered by the Amirlyn Seat to find and bring to justice the members of the Black Ajah that kidnapped them in book two. The trail leads them south towards Tear.
This book has considerably less action than the previous two. Instead it is filled with intrigue, a little politics, and plenty of drama. The pace is much slower than the previous, there is more thinking and planning and unfolding than there is action.
What I liked
It was interesting and kept me reading. And a little suspenseful, though less so than the previous two.
It was funny, in many places. For example, Rand passes through a village on his way to Tear and as he goes by everyone in the village decides to get married. Rand ends up playing the pipes at the wedding celebrations that last all day long and leave the poor villagers all exhausted. When Moirraine, Perrin, Lan, and Loial come through the village on Rand's trail, Moirraine's explanation is: the pattern of the ages shifts around Rand.
Another example: The bunch following Rand stop in an inn in Illian where a girl is dancing and singing and playing the harp. All her songs involve either a man who makes a complete idiot of himself by the end or a woman who ends up completely naked. Sometimes both. And in improbable and hilarious circumstances. Very clever.
I also liked the character development in this book.
It's also a little scary, what with all the creepy gray men skulking in shadows and trying to stick knives in peoples backs or shoot them with crossbows.
And the dream world is a pretty imaginative and cool idea.
What I didn't like
Oh the drama. Same as the last two in that respect. The series is kind of frustrating with all its drama. Part of me wants to give it up altogether but I'm just curious enough to crack open the next book... And once I have, the suspense in that one keeps me reading.
Conclusion
I guess I have to rate it the same as the previous one. 4/5 shadowy assassins.
Friday, July 9, 2010
This Little Church Stayed Home: A Faithful Church in Deceptive Times by Gary E. Gilley
Summary
Gary E. Gilley describes the world of post-modernism and its dangers to the Christian church.
Included are a critique of The Purpose Driven Life by Rick Warren, an explanation and critique of Christian Mysticism, and the same for the Emerging Church in his last few chapters.
His major beef with post-modernism is its rejection of absolute. In Christian churches post-modernism manifests as a soft peddling of the gospel, a casual dismissiveness about the inerrancy of the Scriptures, and a watering down of the fundamental doctrines of Christianity.
Gilley criticizes these churches for selling out to gain greater memberships.
What I liked
I agree with most of what Gilley teaches and would probably endorse most of it. Also, his chapter on church discipline is very good, however...
What I didn't like
To begin with, Gilley's summaries of pre-modernism, modernism, and post-modernism are extremely simplistic. His explanation is a little too 'black and white'. This is a forgivable offense, however, because, for the purposes of his book, they are adequate and, for most readers the brief and narrow summary he provides is sufficient.
Second, I found that Gilley used far too few specific examples. He makes many bold criticisms but fails to support them with specific examples. For example, in his criticism of The Purpose Driven Life, he writes:
"If Warren is writing for new believers, which seems to be the case due to the elementary tone and substance of the whole book, he again misses the mark, for he uses many expressions and biblical references that would be unfamiliar to the novice. On the other hand, if he is writing for the mature, he has wasted paper, for any semi-well taught believer will be bored with this book. So, while much praise will surely be lavished on The Purpose Driven Life, it escapes me who will really profit" (p.90).
I find this paragraph insufficient and wasteful. He says that The Purpose Driven Life, "Uses many expressions and biblical references that would be unfamiliar to the novice" but expressions and biblical references such as what? And what is it in this book that will bore any semi-well taught believer? As it stands, this paragraph seems mean-spirited.
Further into his critique of The Purpose Driven Life I found this paragraph:
"A more common form of misuse of Scripture is taking passages out of context. Warren gives this exaggerated promise: 'If you have felt hopeless, hold on! Wonderful changes are going to happen in your life as you begin to live it on purpose', followed up with this quote from Jeremiah 29:11: 'I know what I am planning for you ... I have good plans for you, not plans to hurt you. I will give you hope and a good future' (p. 31). Unfortunately, this is a promise to Israel concerning their future, not a general promise for all people (even Christians) at all times. Just a few chapters later the promise is reversed: 'Behold, I am watching over them for harm and not for good...' (44:27). In Lamentations 3:38 the same prophet writes, 'Is it not from the mouth of the Most High that both good and ill go forth?' It is strange how people love to claim Jeremiah 29:11 and ignore passages such as these last two. I have yet to find anyone who has claimed Jeremiah 44:27 as their life's verse" (p. 96).
He criticizes Warren for quoting Scripture out of context, but fails to establish the proper context in his critique. That would have been more helpful than the mocking tone he adopts in this paragraph.
These are only two examples of his failure to properly support his arguments, and they were gleaned at a glance. Further rereading would certainly come up with many more.
In his second last chapter, the one on the Emergent Church, Gilley quotes from an interview with Rob Bell and his wife Kristen as a representative of the Emergent Church. What Gilley quotes makes it seem like they are saying that the Bible is subjective. However, it's difficult to tell because Gilley bases this assumption on only two or three quotes lifted from the article and expects us to take his word for it, without further supporting this argument from Rob Bell's actual teachings. Personally, I doubt that Rob Bell believes the Bible is subjective the way Gilley says he does. I could be wrong, but it will take some better-supported arguments to convince me.
Lastly, (this has gone on long enough already, I know...) I felt that the book failed to deliver what it promised in its title. The title of the book is This Little Church Stayed Home: A Faithful Church in Deceptive Times but the book does not describe what a 'faithful church in deceptive times' looks like. Instead it is wholly occupied with what we'd have to call 'the unfaithful church' and why and how it is unfaithful. There is very little positive instruction in this book about how to build and maintain a church that is faithful in deceptive times.
Conclusion
Grudgingly, I have to admit that I agree with almost all of Gilley's critiques. The ones I disagree with are inconsequential. I found The Purpose Driven Life a little too self-centered and a little too 'worksy' when I read it (and Janelle seems to agree), and that is precisely what Gilley points out in his own critique of that book.
Gilley comes across as a little mean-spirited sometimes. However, I know this isn't his intention, but it's the impression he makes.
Overall, I think I would look for a different book on the same subject. I give it 2/5 sold-out churches.
Gary E. Gilley describes the world of post-modernism and its dangers to the Christian church.
Included are a critique of The Purpose Driven Life by Rick Warren, an explanation and critique of Christian Mysticism, and the same for the Emerging Church in his last few chapters.
His major beef with post-modernism is its rejection of absolute. In Christian churches post-modernism manifests as a soft peddling of the gospel, a casual dismissiveness about the inerrancy of the Scriptures, and a watering down of the fundamental doctrines of Christianity.
Gilley criticizes these churches for selling out to gain greater memberships.
What I liked
I agree with most of what Gilley teaches and would probably endorse most of it. Also, his chapter on church discipline is very good, however...
What I didn't like
To begin with, Gilley's summaries of pre-modernism, modernism, and post-modernism are extremely simplistic. His explanation is a little too 'black and white'. This is a forgivable offense, however, because, for the purposes of his book, they are adequate and, for most readers the brief and narrow summary he provides is sufficient.
Second, I found that Gilley used far too few specific examples. He makes many bold criticisms but fails to support them with specific examples. For example, in his criticism of The Purpose Driven Life, he writes:
"If Warren is writing for new believers, which seems to be the case due to the elementary tone and substance of the whole book, he again misses the mark, for he uses many expressions and biblical references that would be unfamiliar to the novice. On the other hand, if he is writing for the mature, he has wasted paper, for any semi-well taught believer will be bored with this book. So, while much praise will surely be lavished on The Purpose Driven Life, it escapes me who will really profit" (p.90).
I find this paragraph insufficient and wasteful. He says that The Purpose Driven Life, "Uses many expressions and biblical references that would be unfamiliar to the novice" but expressions and biblical references such as what? And what is it in this book that will bore any semi-well taught believer? As it stands, this paragraph seems mean-spirited.
Further into his critique of The Purpose Driven Life I found this paragraph:
"A more common form of misuse of Scripture is taking passages out of context. Warren gives this exaggerated promise: 'If you have felt hopeless, hold on! Wonderful changes are going to happen in your life as you begin to live it on purpose', followed up with this quote from Jeremiah 29:11: 'I know what I am planning for you ... I have good plans for you, not plans to hurt you. I will give you hope and a good future' (p. 31). Unfortunately, this is a promise to Israel concerning their future, not a general promise for all people (even Christians) at all times. Just a few chapters later the promise is reversed: 'Behold, I am watching over them for harm and not for good...' (44:27). In Lamentations 3:38 the same prophet writes, 'Is it not from the mouth of the Most High that both good and ill go forth?' It is strange how people love to claim Jeremiah 29:11 and ignore passages such as these last two. I have yet to find anyone who has claimed Jeremiah 44:27 as their life's verse" (p. 96).
He criticizes Warren for quoting Scripture out of context, but fails to establish the proper context in his critique. That would have been more helpful than the mocking tone he adopts in this paragraph.
These are only two examples of his failure to properly support his arguments, and they were gleaned at a glance. Further rereading would certainly come up with many more.
In his second last chapter, the one on the Emergent Church, Gilley quotes from an interview with Rob Bell and his wife Kristen as a representative of the Emergent Church. What Gilley quotes makes it seem like they are saying that the Bible is subjective. However, it's difficult to tell because Gilley bases this assumption on only two or three quotes lifted from the article and expects us to take his word for it, without further supporting this argument from Rob Bell's actual teachings. Personally, I doubt that Rob Bell believes the Bible is subjective the way Gilley says he does. I could be wrong, but it will take some better-supported arguments to convince me.
Lastly, (this has gone on long enough already, I know...) I felt that the book failed to deliver what it promised in its title. The title of the book is This Little Church Stayed Home: A Faithful Church in Deceptive Times but the book does not describe what a 'faithful church in deceptive times' looks like. Instead it is wholly occupied with what we'd have to call 'the unfaithful church' and why and how it is unfaithful. There is very little positive instruction in this book about how to build and maintain a church that is faithful in deceptive times.
Conclusion
Grudgingly, I have to admit that I agree with almost all of Gilley's critiques. The ones I disagree with are inconsequential. I found The Purpose Driven Life a little too self-centered and a little too 'worksy' when I read it (and Janelle seems to agree), and that is precisely what Gilley points out in his own critique of that book.
Gilley comes across as a little mean-spirited sometimes. However, I know this isn't his intention, but it's the impression he makes.
Overall, I think I would look for a different book on the same subject. I give it 2/5 sold-out churches.
Sunday, July 4, 2010
in Kapuskasing
So, we're finally in Kapuskasing. It's very humid, I'm sitting in dad's leather chair and my clothes is sticking to my skin because i'm so sweaty!!
I'm also procrastinating... i should be doing some reading because i'm supposed to preach tonight...
The women (my mom, Leanne, Sophie, Grandmaman, Jelena, Janelle) are playing a word game at the kitchen table...
Chad is downstairs in the cool, cool basement (why aren't I there?) preparing his gospel message...
Dad is napping. I think.
We had quite the trip, getting here. Friday morning, Janelle and I flew into Toronto with Porter airline, so we landed at the city center airport on Toronto Island. We walked over to Union Station, lugging our luggage (that's why it's called luggage, you lug it) all the way. It took longer than I expected. So we headed north on the subway to Yorkdale Mall where we went to the theatre and watched Eclipse. It was interesting. Not my favourite, by far. A vampire soap opera, where the vampires are made of toilets. But it was kind of funny and had enough action to keep me interested.
Afterwards we went to the food court, but there was nowhere to sit down, so (and by now we were exhausted and ravenous) we took the subway again to Lawrence Center and had lunch in the vacant food court there. Teriyaki Chicken on Rice and Dumplings. It was both delicious and filling, and Janelle and I shared both dishes between us.
We wandered around the mall a little and then took the subway to our favourite bubble tea place near our old apartment. (The one we lived in when we lived in Toronto). But they were out of bubble tea, which was a massive disappointment. By now we were almost late to meet Chad and Leanne back at Yorkdale. So we went to the bus stop to catch the bus back to the subway station. The bus stop was just outside of Janelle's friend, Michelle's apartment building and Janelle said something like, "I wish I had time to buzz Michelle and see if she was home!" At that same moment she turned around and saw Michelle leaving the building!!! So we hugged and visited while we waited for the bus and then took the bus together up the street. Michelle got off before us and we continued to Eglington Station, where we switched buses. The next bus we took was supposed to take us to Glencairn station, but we'd never taken it before so we were watching for our stop. We ended up getting off a bit too soon and had to walk about five blocks to get to the subway station. By this time, Chad and Leanne and Jelena had been waiting for us for a few minutes at Yorkdale Mall. Anyways, we finally made it, and then we got Bubble Tea there and it was delicious.
Then we got in the car and headed North. Jelena finished off our Bubble Teas because she LOVED the bubbles so much and I fell asleep. Then we pulled in at the Lachance's in Barrie where we spent the night. Fortunately, I was able to stay awake while we visited with Mrs. Lachance and Mitchell.
In the morning we had a massive breakfast. Yum! And headed out again. We stopped for lunch in North Bay at Leanne's grandparent's house, and continued on. We made it to my parent's house in Val-Rita in time for a late, late supper... Leanne had morning sickness in Moonbeam. (!!!!!)
I'm also procrastinating... i should be doing some reading because i'm supposed to preach tonight...
The women (my mom, Leanne, Sophie, Grandmaman, Jelena, Janelle) are playing a word game at the kitchen table...
Chad is downstairs in the cool, cool basement (why aren't I there?) preparing his gospel message...
Dad is napping. I think.
We had quite the trip, getting here. Friday morning, Janelle and I flew into Toronto with Porter airline, so we landed at the city center airport on Toronto Island. We walked over to Union Station, lugging our luggage (that's why it's called luggage, you lug it) all the way. It took longer than I expected. So we headed north on the subway to Yorkdale Mall where we went to the theatre and watched Eclipse. It was interesting. Not my favourite, by far. A vampire soap opera, where the vampires are made of toilets. But it was kind of funny and had enough action to keep me interested.
Afterwards we went to the food court, but there was nowhere to sit down, so (and by now we were exhausted and ravenous) we took the subway again to Lawrence Center and had lunch in the vacant food court there. Teriyaki Chicken on Rice and Dumplings. It was both delicious and filling, and Janelle and I shared both dishes between us.
We wandered around the mall a little and then took the subway to our favourite bubble tea place near our old apartment. (The one we lived in when we lived in Toronto). But they were out of bubble tea, which was a massive disappointment. By now we were almost late to meet Chad and Leanne back at Yorkdale. So we went to the bus stop to catch the bus back to the subway station. The bus stop was just outside of Janelle's friend, Michelle's apartment building and Janelle said something like, "I wish I had time to buzz Michelle and see if she was home!" At that same moment she turned around and saw Michelle leaving the building!!! So we hugged and visited while we waited for the bus and then took the bus together up the street. Michelle got off before us and we continued to Eglington Station, where we switched buses. The next bus we took was supposed to take us to Glencairn station, but we'd never taken it before so we were watching for our stop. We ended up getting off a bit too soon and had to walk about five blocks to get to the subway station. By this time, Chad and Leanne and Jelena had been waiting for us for a few minutes at Yorkdale Mall. Anyways, we finally made it, and then we got Bubble Tea there and it was delicious.
Then we got in the car and headed North. Jelena finished off our Bubble Teas because she LOVED the bubbles so much and I fell asleep. Then we pulled in at the Lachance's in Barrie where we spent the night. Fortunately, I was able to stay awake while we visited with Mrs. Lachance and Mitchell.
In the morning we had a massive breakfast. Yum! And headed out again. We stopped for lunch in North Bay at Leanne's grandparent's house, and continued on. We made it to my parent's house in Val-Rita in time for a late, late supper... Leanne had morning sickness in Moonbeam. (!!!!!)
From Dawn to Decadence by Jacques Barzun (Part 3)
The "Artist" is Born
Another fairly boring chapter. This one discusses the movement away from the trade guilds and towards the individual artist. I don't really, really understand how it all works because I wasn't paying much attention because it was really boring but it seems like people in trade guilds stopped seeing their techniques as trade secrets to be kept within the guild. They trained themselves and developed technique and wrote about them in books that allowed other people--not guildmen--to study and learn techniques of the different trades.
From there, it seems, you get the great artists of the Renaissance. A good part of this chapter talks about the artists of the Renaissance and what they did and what made them famous and why they are remarkable.
The interesting part of this chapter was the one that talked about how people who we would think of as children made much of themselves at very young ages. He lists as example Richard II, who at fourteen years old, "alone in a large field, faced Wat Tyler's massed rebels and pacified them with a speech" (page 84). Also, Rossini, who at fourteen first conducted an orchestra and led the Bologna Philharmonic at eighteen. Pitt the younger was Prime Minister in England at 23. Lagrange was professor of Mathematics at the Turin School of Artillery at only nineteen. And the list goes on. I was very impressed.
Another section of note was Barzun's A Digression on a Word where he explains the meaning of the word Man, meaning human and not male human. Also worth the read.
So, all in all, a boring chapter with a few interesting and exciting parts.
Another fairly boring chapter. This one discusses the movement away from the trade guilds and towards the individual artist. I don't really, really understand how it all works because I wasn't paying much attention because it was really boring but it seems like people in trade guilds stopped seeing their techniques as trade secrets to be kept within the guild. They trained themselves and developed technique and wrote about them in books that allowed other people--not guildmen--to study and learn techniques of the different trades.
From there, it seems, you get the great artists of the Renaissance. A good part of this chapter talks about the artists of the Renaissance and what they did and what made them famous and why they are remarkable.
The interesting part of this chapter was the one that talked about how people who we would think of as children made much of themselves at very young ages. He lists as example Richard II, who at fourteen years old, "alone in a large field, faced Wat Tyler's massed rebels and pacified them with a speech" (page 84). Also, Rossini, who at fourteen first conducted an orchestra and led the Bologna Philharmonic at eighteen. Pitt the younger was Prime Minister in England at 23. Lagrange was professor of Mathematics at the Turin School of Artillery at only nineteen. And the list goes on. I was very impressed.
Another section of note was Barzun's A Digression on a Word where he explains the meaning of the word Man, meaning human and not male human. Also worth the read.
So, all in all, a boring chapter with a few interesting and exciting parts.
Tuesday, June 29, 2010
The Next 100 Years: A Forecast for the 21st Century by George Friedman
Summary
I'm not entirely sure how to summarize this book. Writing it must have been a massive undertaking.
The author, George Friedman, is a professional forecaster. He is the founder of STRATFOR--a private firm that specializes in intelligence gathering and forecasting--so when it comes to geopolitics, this guy knows his stuff.
And geopolitics is what this book is all about. It begins by identifying the trends in modern human history (and by modern, I mean the past five hundred or so years). And most of this book is occupied with trends in history.
First, Friedman identifies a particular trend or set of trends and briefly explains how they shaped the recent past and the present. Then he explains how these trends will shape the future in several different scenarios. Lastly, he explains why one of these scenarios seems most likely to him.
He separates the future into decades, each with its own crisis and solution.
What I liked
This book is extremely imaginative. And imagination always scores big points with me. By imaginative, I don't mean that it is fanciful or fantastical, I just mean that it requires a good bit of imagination to do what Friedman does so well in this book: expect the unexpected. His predictions are not unlikely, but they are surprising.
Also imaginative are his predictions about the future of warfare. He describes how warfare in the 21st century will be fought from space on orbital platforms (called Battle Stars--just because it sounds cool) that can coordinate strikes by robotic hypersonic aircraft and infantry in powered suits. These predictions are based on current military research.
His writing style is phenomenal. It is almost conversational but his sentences are well structured into strong paragraphs that are easy to read and follow and understand. He doesn't make his thought process inaccessible: first he explains his methods, and then he writes in a way that makes the mechanics of global politics and grand strategy and economics understandable to the layman.
What I liked most was how this book set the events of the present and recent past into the bigger historical picture. It helped me see how events of the present that seem so catastrophic and important will be insignificant in as little as ten or twenty years. He uses examples from the past. For example, in the opening chapters he explains how the current economic recession is not a unique event in the history of this century but that there were other economic crises, all based on investors thinking that current economic trends would never change. All previous economic crises were solved by government bailouts and were followed by periods of economic growth. He demonstrates that this economic recession is only one of many in the recent past and not an unprecedented crisis.
What I didn't like
Almost nothing. The book got a little boring at times when it focused on the tiny details of future events.
Conclusion
I definitely recommend this book to anyone who's not dead yet. It broadened my understanding of current events in the greater historical picture and identified major trends in history of which I had been unaware. I give it a 4.9/5 Battle Stars.
Monday, June 21, 2010
The Great Hunt by Robert Jordan
Summary
In book one of the long The Wheel of Time series, Rand al'Thor escaped the darkspawn that sought to capture and enslave him and, with the company of his friends, stopped the blinding of the Eye of the World, thereby ensuring that the Dark Lord stayed imprisoned in the mountain of Shayol Ghul.
Sound complicated? That's only the first of, so far, twelve books and the twelfth book is being published in three volumes.
The Great Hunt is book two. It begins a few weeks after the events of book one. Rand al'Thor still won't believe that he's destined to be the Dragon Reborn. Mostly because he doesn't want to be the bad guy who ultimately breaks the world in order to destroy the Dark Lord. He just wants a normal life. But a normal life is just not what he's getting. The love of his life, Egwene is heading off to Tar Valon to become an Aes Sedai (think Lord of the Ring's Gandalf with PMS) and will be unlikely to marry anyone. Especially not him.
Then the fabled Horn of Valere turns up in, of all places, the strong room of Lord Agelmar's castle--Fal Dara--which happens to be where Rand al'Thor and his friends from book one are hanging out. But before Rand even finds out about the Horn, it gets stolen by Darkfriends and Trollocs who take it, not towards the Dark Lord at Shayol Ghul like everyone expects, but in the opposite direction.
So, Rand, thinking that he's taking charge of his own destiny, volunteers to go after the Horn with the hunting party sent by Lord Agelmar. Rand ends up being the Hero who recovers the Horn, and then loses it again. And then goes across the whole continent to find it again at the place where everyone seems to be going these days--Toman's Head. But Legendary Artur Hawkwing's armies have returned with their monsters and leashed magical women and have taken the one city where everything comes to a head. Along for the party are a legion of Whitecloaks, some undercover Aes Sedai, and still more Darkfriends, and maybe even the Dark Lord himself, because what kind of party would it be if he didn't think it was worth crashing? Will it be an adventure to remember? You bet.
What I liked
I liked The Great Hunt more than The Eye of the World. I found it more suspenseful, more adventurous, and a little less dramatic. Where The Eye of the World bogged down with back story (because it was the first of the series, it had plenty of explaining to do) The Great Hunt could zip by with brief summaries and allusions because anyone who read the first book got the bigger picture.
Like in The Eye of the World, there was plenty of well written suspense with a little action thrown in here and there to make it interesting. I found this book even more suspenseful than book one, and I read through it much more quickly as a result.
What I didn't like
Oh the drama. I had a hard time getting some of the characters, they're just so melodramatic. It seemed, in places, like they act and feel only to push the plot ahead. One character is so unrealistically temperamental that her tantrums would embarrass my two year old niece. Mind you, her temper becomes characteristic of her and I could live with that because it's consistent, if a little unrealistic. It's unrealistic because everyone else takes her seriously and nobody really says anything.
It also seems like Robert Jordan takes the hard line on predestination. There is no making your own destiny where The Wheel of Time is concerned. The Wheel of Time is a giant spinning wheel that spins out the threads of destiny. Each life is a thread and the Wheel weaves its own pattern out of those lives. So, no one has a say in their destiny, the Wheel determines everything.
Which kind of takes the fun out of everything. I mean, what's the point of making any decisions at all if destiny will ultimately trump everything you do?
While I'm on it... The whole Dragon thing also seems to suck all the fun out of the story. He's just too powerful and invulnerable that you can't really relate. It's like unleashing a weapon of mass destruction--there's no glory or nobility about it. (There will be no great stories written about the bureaucrats who deploy nuclear missiles.) So, yeah, it's kind of disappointing to get to the climactic battle and have all the suspense leached out of it when the good guys pull out a talisman and win by overkill.
In conclusion...
Nevertheless, the suspense leading up to that battle is well worth the read.
Not my favourite fantasy series by far, but I think I'll keep reading to the end. Here's my recommendation:
If you're looking for a time consuming fantasy series, this may be the thing for you. Those who like it, like it a lot. I give it 4/5 weapons of mass destruction.
In book one of the long The Wheel of Time series, Rand al'Thor escaped the darkspawn that sought to capture and enslave him and, with the company of his friends, stopped the blinding of the Eye of the World, thereby ensuring that the Dark Lord stayed imprisoned in the mountain of Shayol Ghul.
Sound complicated? That's only the first of, so far, twelve books and the twelfth book is being published in three volumes.
The Great Hunt is book two. It begins a few weeks after the events of book one. Rand al'Thor still won't believe that he's destined to be the Dragon Reborn. Mostly because he doesn't want to be the bad guy who ultimately breaks the world in order to destroy the Dark Lord. He just wants a normal life. But a normal life is just not what he's getting. The love of his life, Egwene is heading off to Tar Valon to become an Aes Sedai (think Lord of the Ring's Gandalf with PMS) and will be unlikely to marry anyone. Especially not him.
Then the fabled Horn of Valere turns up in, of all places, the strong room of Lord Agelmar's castle--Fal Dara--which happens to be where Rand al'Thor and his friends from book one are hanging out. But before Rand even finds out about the Horn, it gets stolen by Darkfriends and Trollocs who take it, not towards the Dark Lord at Shayol Ghul like everyone expects, but in the opposite direction.
So, Rand, thinking that he's taking charge of his own destiny, volunteers to go after the Horn with the hunting party sent by Lord Agelmar. Rand ends up being the Hero who recovers the Horn, and then loses it again. And then goes across the whole continent to find it again at the place where everyone seems to be going these days--Toman's Head. But Legendary Artur Hawkwing's armies have returned with their monsters and leashed magical women and have taken the one city where everything comes to a head. Along for the party are a legion of Whitecloaks, some undercover Aes Sedai, and still more Darkfriends, and maybe even the Dark Lord himself, because what kind of party would it be if he didn't think it was worth crashing? Will it be an adventure to remember? You bet.
What I liked
I liked The Great Hunt more than The Eye of the World. I found it more suspenseful, more adventurous, and a little less dramatic. Where The Eye of the World bogged down with back story (because it was the first of the series, it had plenty of explaining to do) The Great Hunt could zip by with brief summaries and allusions because anyone who read the first book got the bigger picture.
Like in The Eye of the World, there was plenty of well written suspense with a little action thrown in here and there to make it interesting. I found this book even more suspenseful than book one, and I read through it much more quickly as a result.
What I didn't like
Oh the drama. I had a hard time getting some of the characters, they're just so melodramatic. It seemed, in places, like they act and feel only to push the plot ahead. One character is so unrealistically temperamental that her tantrums would embarrass my two year old niece. Mind you, her temper becomes characteristic of her and I could live with that because it's consistent, if a little unrealistic. It's unrealistic because everyone else takes her seriously and nobody really says anything.
It also seems like Robert Jordan takes the hard line on predestination. There is no making your own destiny where The Wheel of Time is concerned. The Wheel of Time is a giant spinning wheel that spins out the threads of destiny. Each life is a thread and the Wheel weaves its own pattern out of those lives. So, no one has a say in their destiny, the Wheel determines everything.
Which kind of takes the fun out of everything. I mean, what's the point of making any decisions at all if destiny will ultimately trump everything you do?
While I'm on it... The whole Dragon thing also seems to suck all the fun out of the story. He's just too powerful and invulnerable that you can't really relate. It's like unleashing a weapon of mass destruction--there's no glory or nobility about it. (There will be no great stories written about the bureaucrats who deploy nuclear missiles.) So, yeah, it's kind of disappointing to get to the climactic battle and have all the suspense leached out of it when the good guys pull out a talisman and win by overkill.
In conclusion...
Nevertheless, the suspense leading up to that battle is well worth the read.
Not my favourite fantasy series by far, but I think I'll keep reading to the end. Here's my recommendation:
If you're looking for a time consuming fantasy series, this may be the thing for you. Those who like it, like it a lot. I give it 4/5 weapons of mass destruction.
Friday, June 11, 2010
From Dawn to Decadence by Jacques Barzun (Part 2)
This morning I finished reading the third chapter, The Good Letters.
In this chapter, Barzun talks about Humanism. It's a very boring chapter. Mostly he talks about the early humanists who went back to the classics of ancient Greece and Rome. He contrasts these early humanists who appreciated classical art and its expression of humanity to the more modern humanists who deify Man.
The early humanists were not completely secular, though they were accused of being worldly by those who were more devoted to the spiritual existence. Many of these humanists were churchmen, priests of the Catholic church. In the final sections of this chapter, Barzun even introduces a series of humanist popes. Anyways, I'm quite fuzzy on the details in this section because I was only half paying attention and the rest of my mind was wandering because it was so boring.
There was, however, one very interesting part. Barzun wrote about Petrarch, giving a brief history of his life and work. Petrarch is the Italian poet after whom the Petrarchan sonnet is named. He was a priest, at least at first, and he became a great celebrity in Italy and Europe as a poet and orator. I certainly recommend reading this brief section (maybe one or three pages).
So, until next time!
In this chapter, Barzun talks about Humanism. It's a very boring chapter. Mostly he talks about the early humanists who went back to the classics of ancient Greece and Rome. He contrasts these early humanists who appreciated classical art and its expression of humanity to the more modern humanists who deify Man.
The early humanists were not completely secular, though they were accused of being worldly by those who were more devoted to the spiritual existence. Many of these humanists were churchmen, priests of the Catholic church. In the final sections of this chapter, Barzun even introduces a series of humanist popes. Anyways, I'm quite fuzzy on the details in this section because I was only half paying attention and the rest of my mind was wandering because it was so boring.
There was, however, one very interesting part. Barzun wrote about Petrarch, giving a brief history of his life and work. Petrarch is the Italian poet after whom the Petrarchan sonnet is named. He was a priest, at least at first, and he became a great celebrity in Italy and Europe as a poet and orator. I certainly recommend reading this brief section (maybe one or three pages).
So, until next time!
Janelle Talks In Her Sleep
Janelle went to bed as soon as she got home from work, poor thing, she was so tired. I went to bed with her and read to her until she fell asleep. After she fell asleep I kept reading to the end of the chapter. When I finished the chapter, I put the book down, took off my glasses and turned off the lights.
Janelle sat upright in bed and said,
"Patrick...?" in a very sleepy sounding voice.
"Patrick, this is very important, you have to listen to me." She took hold of my hand and squeezed it.
"When I'm talking about the man on the radio, I'm not talking about the man on the radio, I'm talking about being interrupted by the person who turned the radio on."
Confused, I leaned in very close and said, "I'm sorry, what are you saying?"
She started over again, "When I'm talking about the man ..." and she stopped. Then she said, "I hear the laughing meanness in your voice. Get me some warm pajamas, I'm freezing."
Janelle sat upright in bed and said,
"Patrick...?" in a very sleepy sounding voice.
"Patrick, this is very important, you have to listen to me." She took hold of my hand and squeezed it.
"When I'm talking about the man on the radio, I'm not talking about the man on the radio, I'm talking about being interrupted by the person who turned the radio on."
Confused, I leaned in very close and said, "I'm sorry, what are you saying?"
She started over again, "When I'm talking about the man ..." and she stopped. Then she said, "I hear the laughing meanness in your voice. Get me some warm pajamas, I'm freezing."
Tuesday, June 8, 2010
Just Another Monday Night In Halifax
So, monday is our (me and janelle) only night off together. since moving in with janelle's parents for the summer, we've decided to make it our date night. it happens to work out quite wonderfully, seeing as we live right smack downtown.
last night, we got up around seven pm and headed to Your Father's Moustache for supper. We had burgers. janelle's was particularly tasty, but i can't remember what it was. mine was really spicy.
afterwards we went to the theater across the street to watch The Killers. it was really funny, but it kept reminding me of Zombieland. in Zombieland, deadly killer zombies pop up everywhere; in The Killers, deadly killer people pop of everywhere. both movies are basically: SURPRISE, WE'RE GOING TO KILL YOU!!!!! but of course, they fail, because it wouldn't be much of a movie if the protagonists died, right.
anyways, after that we went to the economy shoe shop for drinks. it was exceptionally nice. i'd like to make the shoe shop a monday night tradition. then we went home and surfed the interweb, looking for apartments in thunder bay for the fall... because we're moving there.
and then we hit up the 24 hour subway up the street for breakfast as the sun came up. it was super nice.
last night, we got up around seven pm and headed to Your Father's Moustache for supper. We had burgers. janelle's was particularly tasty, but i can't remember what it was. mine was really spicy.
afterwards we went to the theater across the street to watch The Killers. it was really funny, but it kept reminding me of Zombieland. in Zombieland, deadly killer zombies pop up everywhere; in The Killers, deadly killer people pop of everywhere. both movies are basically: SURPRISE, WE'RE GOING TO KILL YOU!!!!! but of course, they fail, because it wouldn't be much of a movie if the protagonists died, right.
anyways, after that we went to the economy shoe shop for drinks. it was exceptionally nice. i'd like to make the shoe shop a monday night tradition. then we went home and surfed the interweb, looking for apartments in thunder bay for the fall... because we're moving there.
and then we hit up the 24 hour subway up the street for breakfast as the sun came up. it was super nice.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)